Reforming the State: fewer privileges, better services, protection of wages and pensions

Prof. Doutor Rui Teixeira Santos
Chairman of the Board
September 2026

The size of the State is a central question of economic policy. The volume of public spending, its composition and the way it is financed influence growth and economic stability. Its effects on inflation and financing conditions depend, however, on the economic cycle and on the interaction between fiscal and monetary policy. Research recommends assessing the quality of public intervention and its results, avoiding mechanical relationships between more spending and more growth, or between less spending and greater efficiency.

We therefore reject indiscriminate privatisation as a response to the size of the State. The literature identifies efficiency gains in many privatised companies, but it does not allow us to assume that private ownership guarantees better results in every sector. In water and waste services, research finds no savings systematically associated with privatisation.

In urban transport, a study of the Barcelona metropolitan area found higher costs among private operators, especially once the costs of contracting and supervision are taken into account. Each decision must therefore weigh competition, regulation, the quality and continuity of services, investment and the country’s strategic autonomy. Where strategic companies are concerned, the immediate proceeds of a sale must be assessed together with the transfer of control and of future income.

Economic policy must go hand in hand with social policy. This requires restoring strategic planning as a public function: setting development priorities, coordinating investment and assessing results over time. Recent research on industrial policy supports this approach, showing that its effects depend on the instruments used, the institutions involved and the specific conditions of each economy. We advocate a public strategy that links productivity, business capacity and well-being.

We propose a gradual reduction in the weight of public spending, keeping growth in controllable expenditure below the sustained growth of public revenue, adjusted for cyclical effects and one-off revenue, including temporary increases linked to changes in international prices. In a purely illustrative example, if sustained revenue growth is 5%, spending could grow by 4%: 80% of the revenue growth rate, a difference of one percentage point. For the ratio of public spending to GDP to fall as well, spending would need to grow more slowly than nominal GDP.

This approach should form part of multiannual programming, prevent temporary revenue from funding permanent commitments and preserve the State’s capacity to respond to recessions. Reducing the number of ministries or merging services does not guarantee net savings.

In a study of the Danish municipal reform, savings achieved in some areas were offset by increased spending in others, with no overall reduction in costs. In Portugal, any reorganisation must demonstrate the expected gains, account for transition costs and set verifiable commitments on the quality and accessibility of services. We call on the current Government to present the results of the mergers it is promoting: net savings, response times and quality of service. Reducing administrative structures is only justified when it delivers demonstrable benefits for citizens and for the public finances.

The adjustment must preserve the purchasing power of wages and pensions, essential social transfers and investment with a demonstrable economic and social return. Social protection must be accompanied by effective mechanisms to prevent and combat fraud and abuse. As for public investment, we reject the idea that it can automatically be replaced by private investment. A meta-analysis of 68 studies finds positive effects of public capital on private output, particularly in essential infrastructure. This evidence supports the case for public investment that creates the conditions for business activity and growth.

The first intervention should target unjustified tax benefits, subsidies without results and programmes whose evaluation shows insufficient benefits relative to their costs. An analysis of state and local business incentives in the United States finds localised employment gains, but no robust evidence of wider effects on growth.

We therefore call for a rigorous assessment of every form of support in Portugal, to eliminate excessive rents and unjustified privileges and to preserve the instruments that genuinely contribute to economic and social development. Eliminating unjustified tax benefits can strengthen revenue; redesigning or ending ineffective programmes can reduce spending. These are distinct measures that should contribute to a coherent strategy. We propose independent evaluations, public objectives and periodic review of support, so that taxpayers’ money funds proven results and no longer sustains rents with insufficient collective benefit.

We therefore call for a rigorous assessment of every form of support in Portugal, to eliminate excessive rents and unjustified privileges and to preserve the instruments that genuinely contribute to economic and social development. Eliminating unjustified tax benefits can strengthen revenue; redesigning or ending ineffective programmes can reduce spending. These are distinct measures that should contribute to a coherent strategy. We propose independent evaluations, public objectives and periodic review of support, so that taxpayers’ money funds proven results and no longer sustains rents with insufficient collective benefit.

Papers