Author’s note
This essay offers a critical legal and economic reading of the Final Report of the Working Group for Social Security Reform, published in June 2026. The aim is neither to deny population ageing nor the usefulness of actuarial projection. It is to distinguish responsibilities that public debate tends to merge: the contributory social insurance system, the closed scheme of the Caixa Geral de Aposentações (the civil service pension fund), the citizenship-based social protection system and private savings.
The revision of this version incorporates four methodological requirements: (i) an initial table with three perimeters, three balances and three conclusions; (ii) a legal definition of the variables in the Three-Year Social Insurance Balance Index; (iii) an explicit link to the retirement age already indexed to life expectancy and to the sustainability factor; (iv) an illustrative test of sensitivity and of the cost of changing the retirement age. The discussion of the Report’s institutional design has been removed from the body of the text and moved to a methodological appendix, without personal chronology.
The 2025 outturn figures follow Report No 04/2026 of the Public Finance Council. The FEFSS figures follow the Working Group’s Report (2025 closing) and public information on the first half of 2026. Wherever average pensions from different populations are compared, that limitation is flagged.
Contents
Introduction — The problem begins with the diagnosis
Part I — What the Report proposes
Part II — Perimeter, figures and method
Part III — An alternative reform
Conclusion
Appendix A — Three diagnoses, three responses
Appendix B — Methodological transparency (outside the main argument)
